Italian Thanksgiving: Pasta Before the Turkey, Explained
By Nico Ferraro · November 8, 2026 · 8 min read
On New York menus, an Italian Thanksgiving is the American holiday of Thursday, November 26, 2026, with Italian courses such as pasta, risotto or soup around the turkey; none of the sources read defines it as a holiday of its own. Italy’s bishops’ conference does list a separate Giornata Nazionale del Ringraziamento, on Sunday, November 8, 2026, built around a Mass for the farming world. Four New York restaurants print Thanksgiving 2026 dishes, and they put the pasta in a course of its own, in the opening course or among the mains. Menu details come from each restaurant’s website, read in October 2026; definitions and dates come from Treccani, the U.S. Office of Personnel Management and the bishops’ conference.
What is an Italian Thanksgiving?
Thanksgiving itself is American. Treccani, the Italian encyclopedia institute, calls it a religious and civil festival of the United States, set up by the Pilgrim Fathers in New England to give thanks to God and made official under Abraham Lincoln in 1863. The Office of Personnel Management lists Thanksgiving Day 2026 as Thursday, November 26, and National Geographic describes the table as “turkey, potatoes, cranberries, stuffing, and more.” Treccani passages and the bishops’ conference page are translated here.
“Italian” is a label added on top. Of the pages read, only Eataly applies it, heading its holiday page “Thanksgiving all’Italiana,” while its own roast turkey page concedes that “Thanksgiving might not be an Italian holiday.” No source read dates when Italian-American families began serving pasta before the turkey, so no history is claimed; the definition above is only what the menus print. A different Italian-American holiday table, Christmas Eve, is covered in the Feast of the Seven Fishes explainer.
What is Thanksgiving in Italian?
Treccani’s dictionary gives “Giorno del Ringraziamento” as the translation of Thanksgiving Day and calls it a national holiday of the United States. The Italian bishops’ conference lists a day with a similar name and a different shape: the 76th Giornata Nazionale del Ringraziamento for Sunday, November 8, 2026, hosted by the diocese of Chioggia, with a Eucharistic celebration for the agricultural world and stands for associations. The page also lists a study seminar the day before, and describes no dinner.
Turkey is not unfamiliar in Italy. Treccani’s entry on tacchino places the wild common turkey across North America and says smaller domestic breeds are common in Italy, especially in Emilia and the South; among its examples is “un arrosto di t.,” a roast of turkey.
Where does the pasta go on a New York Thanksgiving menu?
Five New York restaurants carry a Thanksgiving menu on their own sites, dated November 26 or titled 2026, and four list dishes. Eataly’s PDF adds a fifth set of dishes, but its text names neither a year nor a location, so it is treated as a national example, not a New York menu.
| Where the pasta sits | Restaurant | What the page prints |
|---|---|---|
| Its own course | Ai Fiori | Courses Antipasti, Pasta, Entrée, Dolce; four dishes under Pasta |
| Inside the opening choice | Cafe Fiorello | Appetizers “choose one,” including tortellini with butternut squash; turkey is the only main |
| Opening choice and a main | L’Amico | Squash soup with fontina agnolotti among appetizers; raviolini under Entrees |
| Instead of the turkey | Tucci | Lasagna and cacio e pepe in the same “Choice of 1” main course as the turkey |
| A shared first-course slot | Eataly (national; PDF names no year or location) | First Course, choose one: pasta or soup, ahead of the turkey course |
| Family style, no dishes listed | il Buco | A 5-course menu on Bond Street, a 4-course on Great Jones Street |
Pasta as its own course
Ai Fiori, at 400 5th Avenue in The Langham, titles its page “Thanksgiving 2026” and calls it a four-course prix fixe. Its Pasta list holds tagliatelle with white truffle, squid ink trofie, veal breast and reblochon ravioli, and a mushroom risotto, ahead of an entrée list where the roasted heritage turkey is one of three choices.
Pasta inside the opening course
Cafe Fiorello, at 1900 Broadway, lists a Thanksgiving menu for November 26. Its PDF offers a choose-one appetizer list that includes wild mushroom risotto and tortellini with butternut squash, pancetta, sage and brown butter, then a single main course of herb-roasted turkey. (The PDF’s embedded text lists the risotto and tortellini after Dessert; the printed page places both under Appetizers.) L’Amico, at 849 Avenue of the Americas, dates its menu November 26, 2026 and puts a butternut squash soup with fontina agnolotti among its appetizers, so the pasta rides inside the soup. Its raviolini sits under Entrees beside the turkey.
Pasta against the turkey
Tucci, at 643 Broadway, describes a three-course Thanksgiving menu for November 26, 2026. Its main course is “Choice of 1,” and the list includes the Norbest Family Turkey, a lasagna of eggplant, zucchini, marinara, ricotta and mozzarella, and cacio e pepe e tartufo. On Tucci’s regular dinner menu both pastas sit under Primi, so the holiday format turns them from a first course into rivals of the bird. Read literally, a guest who picks the lasagna skips the turkey.
Eataly and il Buco
Eataly’s prix-fixe PDF, linked from its Thanksgiving page, runs Appetizer, First Course, Second Course and Dessert. The first course is “choose one”: butternut squash ravioli, mushroom ragù tagliatelle or butternut squash soup, plus two more pastas marked as supplements. The second course opens with roasted turkey breast.
The il Buco family’s events page lists Thursday, November 26th menus at il Buco, 47 Bond Street, and at il Buco Alimentari & Vineria, 53 Great Jones Street. It calls both family-style, with five courses on Bond Street and four on Great Jones Street, but lists no dishes.
How many courses does a Thanksgiving menu have?
The count tracks where the pasta sits. Tucci says three courses, and L’Amico and Cafe Fiorello print three headings, so a pasta on those menus has two homes: the opener or the main. Of the five menus that print dishes (four in New York, plus Eataly’s national one), the three with three sections all fold the pasta into another slot. The two with four sections give it one: a Pasta course at Ai Fiori, and a First Course shared with soup at Eataly. Everyday menus label these courses differently; see what a primi course means on an Italian menu and how NYC menus label the Italian meal courses in order.
What pasta do Thanksgiving menus serve?
Squash is the thread. Butternut squash sits in a soup or a pasta dish at three of the five menus that print dishes: Cafe Fiorello, L’Amico and Eataly’s national PDF. None of Ai Fiori’s four pasta dishes names squash, and lasagna appears once, at Tucci. Treccani defines lasagna as boiled egg-pasta strips layered with besciamella and other ingredients, typical of Emilian and Romagnol cooking; Tucci’s page lists marinara, ricotta and mozzarella and does not mention besciamella.
One Italian word covers both a turkey’s stuffing and a ravioli’s filling. Treccani’s entry on ripieno defines the culinary sense as the mixture of ingredients used to fill animals, vegetables and savory or sweet doughs, and its examples include the filling of ravioli and tortellini and “tacchino r.,” a stuffed turkey. Cafe Fiorello’s PDF pairs a tortellini starter with a turkey served with sausage, mushroom and sage stuffing, so ripieno would describe both the tortellini filling and the turkey stuffing.
What should you ask before booking?
- Is the pasta a course or an alternative? At Tucci it replaces the turkey; at Ai Fiori it is separate.
- Is the turkey the only main? Cafe Fiorello’s PDF lists one main course; Tucci, L’Amico and Ai Fiori list several.
- What does family style mean? il Buco uses the term without defining it.
- Allergies. Eataly’s PDF asks guests to inform the server of allergies or dietary restrictions; confirm with any restaurant.
Prices, service hours and reservation terms change often and are left out here; confirm them with the restaurant.
How these were chosen. A restaurant is used only if its own page prints a Thanksgiving menu labeled November 26 or Thanksgiving 2026, and a dish is counted only if the page lists it. Pages that print no date or year were left out; Eataly’s PDF, which prints neither a year nor a location, appears only as a national example.
Frequently asked questions
What is the Italian version of Thanksgiving?
The Italian bishops’ conference lists a Giornata Nazionale del Ringraziamento, an observance separate from the American holiday. The 76th is set for Sunday, November 8, 2026, hosted by the diocese of Chioggia, and its page lists a Mass for the agricultural world and no family dinner. Separately, Treccani gives Giorno del Ringraziamento as the Italian translation of Thanksgiving Day.
What is served at an Italian Thanksgiving?
On the menus read, an Italian Thanksgiving is turkey with stuffing and gravy, surrounded by Italian courses. As of October 2026, Ai Fiori gives pasta its own course before a turkey entrée, Cafe Fiorello lists tortellini with butternut squash among its appetizers, and Tucci offers lasagna and cacio e pepe as alternatives to its turkey. No source read says which is traditional.
Do Italians celebrate Thanksgiving Day?
Treccani defines Thanksgiving Day as a national holiday of the United States, and Eataly’s own roast turkey page says it “might not be an Italian holiday.” The pages read do not say whether Italian families hold a Thanksgiving dinner, so this piece does not claim it. The one Italian observance with a similar name, the bishops’ conference’s Giornata Nazionale del Ringraziamento, is built around a Mass, not a meal.
What pasta do you serve at Thanksgiving?
Menus read in October 2026 serve filled pasta, soup and layered pasta: tortellini with butternut squash at Cafe Fiorello, squash soup with fontina agnolotti at L’Amico, an eggplant and zucchini lasagna at Tucci and, on Eataly’s national prix-fixe PDF, butternut squash ravioli.


